High Risk, Negligible Reward: America’s foreign policy blunders threaten a core principle of U.S. identity

—
by Byron Shire | 16 Nov. 2026
The U.S. has a deep cultural infatuation with risk. It’s a choice built into Americans’ daily lives
and firmly guides government policy, both foreign and domestic. Under the second Trump
presidency, this value for risk has been on full display with regards to international relations.
This threatens devaluing the American risk-taking principle...to the benefit of the international
community.
Personal conversations...
In the weeks leading up to the Swedish elections this year, I would sit in on conversations
between my partner and his family, as they discussed their options for who to cast their votes for.
These chats played out differently than political discussions I have with my family and friends in
my home country of the U.S. The civil and productive tone between my partner and family
didn’t surprise me, nor did the fact that no one shied away from these conversations. I was,
however, perplexed by how conflicted they’d become when discussing which party(ies) to vote
for. I’m no stranger to dissatisfaction with the electoral options laid before me, but these Swedish
conversations, in my eyes, seemed to get snagged on trivial policy issues - things that wouldn’t
top any polling of voters’ top concerns.
I became a little sarcastic towards my partner, slinging phrases like, oh boo hoo, if only I had
more than 8 options to choose from. Later, when my snarkiness subsided, I began to wonder
exactly why I was so comfortable looking over my options for political representation - which I
can count comfortably on one hand - and selecting one without much internal debate. Yes,
having only two options helps, and, no, having so few has never really felt right to me. But there
is a comfort, a normality in it at this point. And I would think one in the Swedish position would
find more solace in having an option that closer aligns with one’s core values, instead of debating
the purity of that party’s policies.
A culture of risk-taking...
Though, I’ll go ahead and concede that my comfort with a two party system is the greater of two
evils here. At the same time, it makes a lot of sense. Upon reflection, this electoral set up fits
perfectly with the positive attitude towards risk that was continuously reinforced for me growing
up in the states.
Don’t hesitate to take an opportunity, I always heard. Don’t be afraid to lose money or other big
things: the chance at a bigger payoff is more important. And, if something’s not working, don’t hesitate to start from scratch. These principles prompt people to invent big things, move far for
new opportunities, or even start history-changing movements. They also incentivize spending big
- bigger than one can afford - to, say, get a college education, buy a dream home, or drive around
in something flashier than what the neighbors own. With credit, all things are possible.
Now, how exactly does a culture of risk-taking culminate with an electoral system practically
devoid of mold-breaking options? Well, when one spends their life with the mindset of taking as
much risk as possible, one feels the need to do whatever is necessary to translate such risk into
reward...to control outcomes. And, in a culture where self-reliance is prized, a collective
endeavour like government fits more neatly into the category of a liability to manage, rather than
a potential high-reward investment.
We prefer it this way. After all, without risk, there is no reward. And, if government becomes
insistent on reducing risk, then how do we reap our rewards? How do we win big?
What is allowed, however, is a government that delights in our value for risk-taking as much as
we do. It’s appreciated, also, that government does its best to translate such risk into reward as
well.
The risk-taking principle in foreign policy...
An increasingly popular strategy for this nowadays is to spread the liability around. Let friends
and allies face some of the risk. Let enemies absorb some risk as well. America is no stranger to
putting the international community - allies and enemies - in risky situations, with the attempt to
reap long-term rewards for itself. However, in recent years, the desperation for reward has
prompted even riskier action, for short-sighted goals. The swift, long-term repercussions of this
action may be so significant that they critically damage the value of risk-taking in American
culture. It may be for the best, particularly in regards to our international relationships.
An exemplary contemporary proponent of the American risk-taking principle is our incumbent
president Donald Trump. Let’s take his work with Iran as an example. Starting a war with the
Islamic Republic has been part of a streak of bold foreign policy from him - where the limiting
factors of precedent or international law - have both been trumped, in order to finally achieve
some of America’s yearslong global aspirations. In this case, that would be finally toppling the
regime in Iran, and blocking the country from producing a nuclear weapon. The president,
simultaneously applying the risk-taking principle to his personal fortunes, sought the opportunity to enter a crucial election season - the 2026 midterms - as a wartime leader, something that's proven generally positive for the political fortunes of American presidents.
We can also count the invasion of Venezuela and capture of its president Nicholas Maduro as
part of this bold foreign policy streak. Here, Trump swiftly achieved one of America’s long-held policy objectives with, for now, few repercussions making it back to the American people
themselves or Trump’s own political fortunes.
The commonality between the policies towards Iran and Venezuela is that they are risky, yet are
inherently subdued by the fallout from earlier risky American foreign policy decisions. I mean
that neither have, thus far, involved ‘boots on the ground.’ The American public, disillusioned by
the deceptive goals of the war in Iraq and America’s protracted presence in Afghanistan, are not
presently on board with conflict to the extent that American servicemembers must be deployed.
We feel that, this way, we’ll manage to avoid taking the heat at home as we look for big rewards
from international conflict. However, these past two years of Trump foreign policy has ended up
having a significant level of reach back towards the domestic.
Unfortunately for the president, the conflict with Iran has become protracted, in a way that voters weren't willing to praise him for...nor able to cope with themselves. The risks involved with initially waging the war seem to have compounded, and redistributed themselves to Trump and the American people. Fuel prices are off the rails, with no visible end in sight. Simultaneously, Americans feel the effect that another of Trump’s significant foreign policies - the array of trade wars - is having on inflation. Even the established hardline of not dragging service members into conflicts seems dangerously close to being ignored, as Navy sailors in the Middle East were kept working at sea for record-breaking lengths and a ground invasion of Iran doesn’t seem to be out of the question.
Trump reaped no electoral rewards for his bets on foreign policy. The results of the recent
midterm elections were a nasty rebuke of his policies and the man himself. Foreign policy, which
rarely is a top issue for American voters, was among the determining factors in this election, as
right now it ties back to both economic woes and trust in leadership.
All the way up to the election, even when it appeared the natural time for caution had arrived,
Trump full-heartedly employed the risk-taking principle. In an attempt to show he could lower
fuel costs ahead of the election, Trump agreed to a deal on diesel with Russia...and signed on to
Putin’s goal of Western division over Ukraine in the process. The relationship between the White
House and Ukraine has not been filled with certainties, or even pleasantries, at any time since
Trump’s return to office. However, the lifting of sanctions meant to stop money from being
funneled into Putin’s war machine pushed a new boundary in the eroding trust between the U.S.
and Ukraine, plus its European allies. The exact long-term effects of this move on Ukraine’s
security and U.S. foreign relations remain to be seen, but the idea that stakes as high as these
could be eschewed for a fleeting, last-ditch attempt to lessen the blow of the midterms pointed to
the fact that we’re at an inflection point in the risk-taking principle.
Risk and reward beyond 2026...
Even with Trump’s opponents clinching the clearest of victories in the midterms, there is a
question remaining, shared by American voters, American allies, and those America is at war
with: where does the U.S. go from here? At this point in time in particular, we in the U.S. are
noticing that the direction of the country - not simply those leaders pushing us in that direction,
or the few alternatives on the ballot - is not working. A new direction cannot hinge simply on a
switch between regimes. It’s going to have to originate from a concrete stance, taken by the
electorate; and, given we were prepared this November to so firmly reject the products of our
and the president’s risky business, the entire risk-taking framework is called into question.
Americans see compounding uncertainty. Economic woes like inflation, fuel prices, and tariffs
don’t seem to have an expiration date or an exit route. A handful of other domestic issues have
simply fallen out of the spotlight, with solutions not even up for discussion. Our government has
provoked the international community in a litany of ways, starting conflicts that only our own
concessions will be able to end. It’s simply not an appealing environment, where people feel
encouraged to take risks.
As we in the U.S. are restructuring our investments in the coming years as it pertains to our
individuals lives, our collective lives, and our relationships with the international community, the
consequences of risk-taking and shifting risk to others will not present as just trivial
hypotheticals. It will be an ever-present factor to contend with without delay - not an issue in
Washington, not an issue in another state, and not a problem in some land far, far away. These
consequences serve not so much as an opportunity for course correction, but more so as a wall,
which won’t be easy to walk around or dig under.
The practice in particular of shifting our risk to unwilling parties will be harder and harder to
justify, as backlash is swifter and the burden is shared amongst us daily. While it may be a trying
lesson for Americans to learn over the coming years, it may just serve as a safeguard for an
international community emboldened by increasing U.S. threats to sovereignty, yet growing ever
tired of constantly having to deal with a fight they didn’t pick.
Byron Shire is a Bachelor’s student at Stockholm University, studying International Business and Politics. He recently joined the Stockholm Journal as an editorial trustee, where he contributes with experience gained from working on political campaigns back in his home country of the U.S. He enjoys following elections globally and analysing how domestic affairs will shape foreign policy.





Comments